Edward Kimmel from Takoma Park, MD via Wikimedia Commons

ANALYSIS – The horrific mass shooting by a deranged white gunman in Buffalo, New York has prodded the liberal media to breathlessly focus on the ‘great replacement theory.’

This idea posits that Democrats have been aggressively pushing an open-borders immigration policy for decades to replace traditional Americans of European descent with third world migrants more likely to be co-opted by the Left.

Calling it ‘racist,’ ‘fringe,’ ‘extremist,’ ‘discredited,’ and all manner of other epithets, the liberal media, in collusion with the Democrat Party want to turn a simple statement of political fact about an obvious Democrat strategy into some sort of white nationalist conspiracy theory pushed by ugly Republicans.

The UK’s liberal paper, The Guardian writes:

Born from far-right nationalism, the extremist ideology expounding the view that immigration will ultimately destroy white values and western civilization has found favor not only with media figures, such as the conservative Fox News host Tucker Carlson, but a host of elected politicians and others seeking office.

Those who have convinced themselves Democrats are operating an open-door immigration policy to “replace” Republican voters with people of color and keep themselves in power permanently include Congresswoman Elise Stefanik, chair of her party’s House conference, and JD Vance, the Donald Trump-approved Republican nominee to represent Ohio in the US Senate.

After the Buffalo shooting, the pair are among those receiving blowback for embracing the conspiracy theory that the killer referred to repeatedly in an online manifesto authorities believe he posted to justify the attack.

And while anyone who would use any political theory or observation, to commit mass murder like the white nationalist shooter in Buffalo, or the black nationalist shooter in Brooklyn, is likely deranged and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, the facts seem to buttress the general themes of this theory.

There has in fact been a dramatic, overwhelming shift by Democrats to open borders immigration for at least two decades. These left-wing policies have been disproportionately focused on promoting immigration from third world countries and regions rather than Europe.

And while they have at times been ignorantly supported by some Republicans, the result, at least in the short term, generally supports Democrats and their obsession with diversity, multiculturalism, and racial WARfare.

This isn’t a theory. It’s pretty much a fact. And it’s integral to the Democrat electoral strategy.

In fact, in a dramatic shift from 1995, today 43 percent of Democrats are people of color. Most of that non-white growth among Democrats has been among Asian-Americans and Latinos, the two largest sources of immigrant growth in the U.S.

As a conservative American of Hispanic heritage, political analyst, and Spanish media commentator, I have been at the forefront of observing and calling out the Democrat Party’s efforts for years.

Making the point clearly, Republican Senate candidate JD Vance stated at a campaign event in Portsmouth last month: “You’re talking about a shift in the democratic makeup of this country that would mean we never win, meaning Republicans would never win a national election in this country ever again.”

While I disagree with Vance’s emphasis on ‘never’ winning again, since many third world immigrants steadily become more conservative as they break free of the initial leftist indoctrination they receive, the overall idea is valid.

Tucker Carlson, the Fox News host, said it best, and most accurately, on his show last year, when he stated: “Demographic change is the key to the Democratic party’s political ambitions. In order to win and maintain power, Democrats plan to change the population of the country.”

Of course, despite the simple statement of political fact, the Left became apoplectic over his “nefarious” stance, with the Washington Post columnist Greg Sargent writing that the replacement idea: “exposes the ideological underbelly of the broader right-wing populist nationalist movement that he and his defenders champion.”

But not all liberal media have followed this line before.

In 2019, NPR noted how far left the Democrats had moved on immigration in a very short time, essentially reversing their opinion on immigrants since 1994: “The makeup of the Democratic Party has changed, and its base has adopted a fundamentally more progressive attitude on immigration in a relatively short time span, which poses a challenge for party leaders.”

But more pointedly, the liberal Atlantic Monthly in 2017 admitted the Democrat strategy as clearly as can be stated:

Between 2008 and 2016, Democrats became more and more confident that the country’s growing Latino population gave the party an electoral edge. To win the presidency, Democrats convinced themselves, they didn’t need to reassure white people skeptical of immigration so long as they turned out their Latino base. “The fastest-growing sector of the American electorate stampeded toward the Democrats this November,” Salon declared after Obama’s 2008 win. “If that pattern continues, the GOP is doomed to 40 years of wandering in a desert.”

As NPR, The Atlantic, and Salon admitted just a few years ago, the ‘Great Replacement’ isn’t theory, it’s not fringe, and certainly not discredited. Its fact. But today the Left and Democrat Party will do anything and everything to hide it.

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AmericanActionNews.com


  1. It’s the proverbial “Elephant In The Room”. However, now the Dems are saying – “Hey look at our elephant!” They don’t even hide the fact anymore. Just like they don’t hide their gay indoctrination of our children and grandchildren. Or their cheat to win strategies, or their government knows what’s best for you and your health – etc, etc, etc. Wake up people, they have changed the narrative to a point that we won’t be able to change it back even if we’re lucky enough to have a conservative Rep POTUS elected again. But maybe we can get back some of our dignity that this fake administration has lost us.

  2. Every thing the New Socialist Demoncrats do is the Further Destroy and Bring Down Our True American Values!!!!!
    Wake Up America, We Are In Very, Very Serious, Grave and Dire Danger “From Within” by the Washington, DCeivers!!!!

  3. LISTEN UP….GOD’S Blessing is NOT with PREZ BIDEN or the DEMOCRATS. GOD Blessed PREZ TRUMP. Without GOD’S Blessing there is CHAOS…Confusion and ALL Kinds of EVIL. This is GOD’S Planet EARTH. EVERYTHING in it belongs to GOD. From SamuraiQueen. 😄😄😄😇😇😇😁😁😁

  4. Right-wing extremist fanatics ARE the gravest threat to America today . Why ? Because they operate within our birders . Forget about BLM and Antifa . They’re not the problem but. the lying right-wing media has been lying about them and demonizing them from the beginning .

  5. The demonrats will do anything to swing the voting public their way. NO illegal immigrant should have the right to vote in OUR elections! ONLY citizens should. And— bringing in more illegals isn’t fair to natural born citizens of this country! Just try voting in a foreign country if you are not a legal citizen, you would be jailed immediately!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *